Pro Wrestling Torch
Pro Wrestling Torch Reaches The Most Wrestling Fans Every Week: #1 in iTunes • #1 on iPhone and iPad • #1 on Android • #1 on Kindle
iPhone & iPad
Amazon Kindle
Windows Phone
PWTorch Phone App
12/16 WWE Smackdown review: Giebink's Express v3.0 (Hr. 2)

Dec 17, 2004 - 1:05:00 AM

By Dusty Giebink, Torch Team Contributor

WWE Smackdown review
December 16, 2004
Taped 12/14/04 in Nashville, Tenn.
Aired on UPN
Report by Dusty Giebink, Lounge Janitor

If you havent read hour one yet, hit your back button and do so first.

In a nutshell: An excellent match between JBL and Angle that should never have taken place, because you should never have World Title matches on free TV!

***Cole channeled the spirit of Tony Schiavone to start this hour, saying that Layfield vs. Angle for the title would be the greatest main event in the history of Smackdown.

***They then showed a feature on about John Cenas new spinny U.S. Title belt. Needless to say, its completely lame. In any event, this served to set up the feature where they showed the entire Armageddon match between Cena and Jesus. Im going to review it here to fill space in my show review, but I wont treat it like a normal wrestling match, because its already been reviewed 832 times on this website already. Cena started off by pounding away on Jesus. Cena took the action outside and laid into Jesus with the kendo stick after Jesus went after his kidney again. The announcers were having birds about the brutality of the match. The fans were actually going nuts for Cena, so it doesnt matter how little talent he has. If you can get over with crowds, maybe you can draw some money and be a star. I understand the two things arent automatically connected, but with business not exactly flourishing at this point, its worth a shot to push Cena to the moon. Cena chased Carlito away and then pounded away on Jesus, who was prone on the guardrail at this point. He challenged Carlito to come get him some, but Carlito would have none of it. At this point, they inexplicably started showing the match in black and white. To this point, it had been in full color. I have no idea what was going on here, but until proven otherwise, I have to assume this is a WCW-like technical snafu.

They started brawling in the crowd, with Cena stalking Jesus up and down the aisles as Jesus was basically just trying to get away from him. Carlito hit Cena from behind and then hightailed it out of there as fast as he could. Cena stalked after both of them in a pretty methodical fashion, like he was the Frankenstein monster or something. Cena chopped away on Jesus as Cole just suddenly realized that Jesus hadnt really had much offense in this match. Jesus tried something at that point, but to no avail, as Cena no sold it and went back to business. Cena jumped off the guardrail onto Jesus. Tazz said that his performance tonight proved Cena was a thug. Sure. Sure it did. Cena grabbed a trash can lid and a something metal and walloped Jesus over the head with both items. Cena finally hit the F-U to put Jesus and the match out of its misery. At this point, the match went back to color. Dont tell me they switched to black and white to make some kind of artistic statement about how gritty the match was or something. Because that would just be asinine. Carlito tried to grab the chain after the match, but Cena cut him off and took it for himself. He punched Carlito out with it and then celebrated his victory as the fans went completely nuts. God bless him, hes over.

***They showed Layfield taking on Angle in the Play Station 2 Raw vs. Smackdown video game. Unfortunately, they just showed some of the middle portion of the match, and didnt show who won in that match. That made me very sad.

***In the ring, Al Snow introduced the final two contestants in the Tough Enough competition. Mizanin was first. Cole told us he was 24 years old, and could be known from his appearances on reality shows in recent years. Puder is a 23 year old cage fighter from the Ultimate Fighting Championships, according to Cole. Mizanin gave Puder a phony good luck hug when they were both in the ring. Snow said he was proud of both of them, but there could only be one winner. He revealed then that Puder had won the competition. No big surprise there. Anyone that uses the argument against Puder that everyone else in the competition was against him as proof that he didnt deserve to win it isnt looking at the big picture, because they were probably just as likely to be against him because they knew he was the favorite, and if they got rid of him, they would all have that much better a chance to win it themselves. Puder said he has been working as hard as he could to win this competition, and he wasnt going to stop there, because he was going to continue working to prove that he could be a WWE superstar. Snow asked him how he would like to main event WrestleMania next year. Puder obviously said that would be great. Snow said he was glad to hear that, because he just cleared it with Long that the winner of the competition (Puder, duh) would get to be entered into the Royal Rumble, and thus fight for a shot at the champion at WrestleMania. Puder was ecstatic.

***Backstage, Angle said that America needed a hero to look up to in his day and age. Unlike those thugs in basketball that go into the crowd and attack the fans. Unlike the baseball players that break records by cheating and using unsavory tactics. Unlike the hockey players that cant even be bothered to show up for work. The man he had in mind to be this hero? Himself, of course. He has a point there. Reigns told him that he and Jindrak would take out any members of JBLs cabinet if they tried to interfere in the match. Reigns then said that ever since the three-on-one match at the PPV, his back has been killing him. He not so subtly implied that he wished Angle would provide health care to him and Jindrak to take care of such issues. Angle said the important thing was that he had a big match coming up that he had to focus his attention on. Reigns agreed with that. Angle vowed to become a five time World Champion.

***The announcers helpfully reinforced what the aforementioned segment told us, that Angle vs. Layfield for the WWE Title was coming up next.

Until the day comes when a cigarette knocks on my door, jumps into my mouth, lights itself and inhales itself into my lungs, I find it hard to find complete and total fault with the cigarette companies themselves. Lets point the finger in the right place here.

***Creed is a horrible band. Whats more, they broke up. Despite this, WWE is using their song One to promote them coming to the Middle East for next weeks show. In case you forgot you were watching WCW Smackdown, theres just another little reminder for you. Youre welcome. Creed, go away.

(3) Kurt Angle defeated John Bradshaw Layfield by disqualification. The finish came when Orlando Jordan interfered in the match on behalf of Layfield.

The Beginning: Before the match, Teddy Long joined Cole and Tazz in the announce booth. Long said that on next weeks show, it would be Heidenreich vs. Undertaker in the Middle East. I feel even worse for the troops now than I did before. At this point, Joy came out, wearing the skimpiest possible Santa outfit and was tossing candy out to the crowd. No particular reason for this, other than to get another faceless woman on the show. Major Gunns, Madusa, Pamela Paulshock. . . Joy, Amy, Torrie Wilson. . . Oh, sorry. Layfield came to the ring with his entire cabinet, but actually walked down to the ring, and was not aided in any way by his long white limo with the bullhorns on the front. Cole asked Long if it was fair to have Layfield defend his title only four days after having to defend the belt at the PPV against three other guys. Long said he ordered it because it was what the people wanted to see. Joy gave Layfield some Christmas candy, which Amy took offense to. The two women had a catfight which was at least as good as any other catfight in the annals of Smackdown history. They separated the two and Amy said she was calm now, but that was a Vinnie Ru swerve, because she turned around and stripped Joy of her top. Which meant that you could see exactly as much cleavage as you could before she got stripped down. Joy returned the favor to Amy. Long exercised his authority by tossing everyone at ringside from the match and essentially leveling the playing field to just Layfield vs. Angle as the show went to commercial break.

The Middle: Back from commercial break and the match was already in progress. Layfield had Angle backed up in the corner. Angle took Layfield down and worked some holds on him. Layfield got out of it by punching away on Angle with some big time right hands. Angle reversed a whip into the opposite corner and hit a beautiful belly-to-belly on Layfield. Well, even when the show reaches new lows, you can always count on Angle to save things with a stellar in-ring performance. Layfield hit a high elbow (thats three too many for that move on this show, I must add) on Angle. Fans were getting behind Angle here, chanting Lets Go Angle. Layfield hit a suplex into a pinning combination, but only got two. He locked on a pseudo-sleeper rest hold thingie. Angle played complete face here, using the fans cheers as motivation to mount his comeback. Angle tried a belly-to-belly, but Layfield sort of blocked it. So Angle locked on the anklelock. Layfield managed to get to the ropes to break things up, thankfully for him. Outside the ring, Layfield whipped Angle into the 20,410 pound steel ring steps. At this juncture (like that?!) in the match, they went to their final commercial break.

Because some 8,000 year old guy stepped out in front of a car that you should have been able to clearly see coming, that even had its lights on, you shouldnt do drugs.

Back from break, and Layfield had Angle in a hold of some type. Tazz identified it as a top wristlock right after I typed that. Thank you, Tazz. Angle armdragged his way out of it. Layfield hit a big time shoulder block take down and then went back to work on the arm. He had on a sort-of cross arm breaker, according to Tazz, but Angle got to the ropes. Layfield worked the arm and shoulder area some, and then went for a slam. Angle wiggled his way out of it and hit an inverted DDT to try to turn the tide in the match. Angle slugged away on Layfield and then knocked him down with a flying forearm. Layfield, however, caught Angles next move attempt and hit a fallaway slam. Tazz said he used to call that a tabletop suplex. I like that. Angle hit a couple German suplexes, another move I think they should ban, because of how it could do permanent damage to a guys neck. Just ask Chris Benoit. Hell, just ask Angle himself. Angle went for the Angle Slam but Layfield countered out of it. Layfield tried to hit a big boot, but Angle ducked out of the way. Angle locked on the anklelock, but Layfield rolled over and countered his way out of it by kicking Angle away. Angle finally hit the Angle Slam. He only got a two count for this. Layfield hit what Tazz identified as a flying armbar on Angle to stem the tide. Layfield signaled that things were over and went for his powerbomb. Angle sunset flipped his way out of it and locked on the anklelock once again. Layfield struggled to get to the ropes as Jordan came out of nowhere to try to break things up. This was hilarious, as he came running in after Angle, who promptly just ducked and backdropped Jordan to the floor. Outside the ring, the Bashams were going at it with Jindrak and Reigns. This allowed Jordan to come back in and waffle Angle with the title belt. Of course, the referee was still concerned more about the stuff going on outside the ring, because we all know that whats happening several feet away from the ring between people that arent even in the match is much more important than that loud thud you just heard behind you in the middle of the ring. In any event, this only got a two count. Angle then once again locked on the anklelock. Jordan ran in for a third time and attacked Angle, this time causing for the disqualification. What a horrid finish.

The End: Layfields cabinet and Angles crew were brawling after the match when Big Show hit the ring. In a night of Dustys pet peeves, I have to point out another one. As Big Show came to the ring, they played his music. Its like theres a guy right behind the curtain where the wrestlers come out to the ring with a stereo and a CD that has everyones entrance music on it. Big Show could calmly walk up to the guy, give him the nod that says Im about to run in there and whip some ass, and the guy could look on his little list, note that Big Shows song is number 12 on this particular mix tape, cue it up and Big Show could be on his way. Honestly, its just another little thing that makes wrestling look even more phony than it has to look. For once, I wish a guy could do a run in without his music playing. You know, if his ego could take that.

So yeah, Show ran in on everyone at this point, for no real discernible reason. He chokeslammed Jindrak and Reigns, and then both Bashams simultaneously. Theres no better way to get the Bashams over as a legitimate, title-worthy tag team than to have them get laid to waste on each and every Smackdown. Show then took out Jordan with his F-500 (the phat version of Brock Lesnars F-5). Which means Lesnar cant be far away from returning to the show. As if this show couldnt get any worse, now it looks like Lesnar is going to return. And who wouldnt welcome back a guy to their company that walked out on them in order to try to become a huge football star. A great guy, a real locker room leader, that would never do something like cheat on his wife, who walked out on the company to pursue some pie in the sky fantasy of becoming a football player because being a pro wrestler was beneath him, and he can just get welcomed back to the company like this. I want to puke. In any event, Show indicted to Layfield that he planned on taking his title belt from him, so it smells like a three way match between Show, Angle and Layfield is in the companys future plans.

Quotes of the Night

Layfield: They say in history, all things come in threes. FDR ending the Great Depression. Ronald Reagan tearing down the Berlin Wall. And last Sunday, in Atlanta, the greatest, the great example of sports entertainment in history just happened. I did not just defeat three people. I defeated three of the greatest WWE superstars of all time thereby etching my name in stone as the champion of all champions.

-After reading Layfield the riot act
Angle: So dont you come out here with your over the top, ridiculous championship celebration. In case you forgot, I invented the over the top, ridiculous championship celebrations, bucko.

Jordan: Everybody knows that JBL is gonna win tonight.
Reigns: Yeah right.
Jordan: Thats right.
Reigns: Youre forgetting something. Kurt Angles an Olympic gold medalist.
Jordan: Well, JBLs the WWE Champion.
Reigns: Kurt Angles a multi-time WWE Champion.
Jordan: JBLs got national radio shows.
Reigns: Big deal. Kurt Angles been honored at the White House.
Jordan: JBL gives to charity.
Reigns: Well, Kurt Angle visits orphans. Sick orphans.
Jordan: JBL helps old people.
Reigns: Kurt Angles kind to animals.
Jordan: JBL gives all his employees full health care and benefits.
Reigns: Did you say full health care?
Jordan: Thats right. And dental, too.
Reigns: Does that include chiropractors?
Jordan: You know, its a very comprehensive plan.
Reigns: No kidding.
Jordan: Wait a minute, you mean to tell me Kurt doesnt do the same?
Reigns: You know what forget it. You tell JBL after that match tonight, hes going to need all the health care he can get.

Tazz: They are the former champs the Golden Warrior and the French Phenom. Lets see if they can handle the likes of Booker T and Eddie Guerrero.
Cole: Its actually the Bronze Warrior.
Tazz: What did I call him?
Cole: Golden. (calls action)
Tazz: Well, sometimes hes gold or platinum. Hes everything. Hes like a multi-metallic, flavored thing or something.

Layfield: I am the champion of all champions. I have overcome more obstacles than anybody in WWE history. I am going to beat Kurt Angle. And I am going to beat Kurt Angle tonight!
Amy Weber: And after tonight, youll be heading overseas to represent Smackdown and the WWE!
Layfield: Overseas?
Weber: Well yeah. The WWE Champion headlines next weeks show in the Middle East. Itll be great for your image.
Layfield: Amy, thats a war zone. I mean, soldiers are fighting, and its great to see them and all, but its a volunteer army, and I didnt volunteer to do anything like that. I dont want to end up on some TV show as a hostage in Decapistan or something.

Carlito: Theodore Long hes out to get you. I know that because hes been after me ever since the day I came to Smackdown. And that? Thats not cool.

Angle: You know, speaking of Major League Baseball, and everything else thats going on in sports today, Ill tell you what America needs. America needs an athlete, a hero. A hero pure of body and spirit. Someone they can look up to. Not like those professional basketball players, those thugs, who attack fans. Or those baseball players who break records but lie and cheat about it. Or the NHL players who dont even show up for work. Im going to be a champion that everyone can respect.
Reigns: You know, if Orlando or any one of JBLs boys gets involved, Im going to take them out.
Angle: Youre damn right.
Reigns: (holding his back) As long as I can.
Jindrak: Whats wrong with you, man?
Reigns: My back, man. Its killing me. Ever since that match Sunday against the Big Show.
Jindrak: Dont remind me.
Reigns: I mean, its hard to find a good doctor these days. Health care is really expensive these days.
Angle: What the hell are you talking about?!
Reigns: You know what, never mind. Well talk about it later.

Long: Next week, Heidenreich will go one on one with the Undertaker, right here on Smackdown from the Middle East. How about that, playa?
Cole: Next week what a holiday gift for the troops!

Cheap Plug: Be sure to check out the Smackdown Lowdown thread in the Lounge Zone of the VIP Forum message board and join Paul Madavi and myself in discussing the latest happenings on Smackdown and anything else you so choose.

***Dusty Giebink now does the Smackdown Express reviews each and every week for He does his for all the readers who would rather watch coherent things and then read the recap later. Bastards! He can be contacted at if you have something to say.

We suggest these recent related articles...
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 10/8: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Thursday show, including Roman Reigns & Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt & Braun Strowman
METZGER'S ROH TV REPORT 10/4 & 10/7: IWGP World champ Okada vs. Roderick Strong main event, plus Briscoes vs. Time Splitters, more from "Field of Honor," Overall Reax
MCMAHON'S TNA IMPACT REPORT 10/7: TNA Title Series kicks off, Bound for Glory fall-out, more; Overall Reax




RAW POLL 10/12: Vote on Monday's show free polls

RAW POLL 10/12: What was the Best Match on Raw? free polls
MCNEILL LIVECAST POLL: TNA will have a 32-person tournament to determine a new Hvt. champion - your thoughts? free polls
CENA POLL: If John Cena takes a year-end break, who should win the U.S. Title from Cena? free polls





PWTorch editor Wade Keller has covered pro wrestling full time since 1987 starting with the Pro Wrestling Torch print newsletter. launched in 1999 and the PWTorch Apps launched in 2008.

He has conducted "Torch Talk" insider interviews with Hulk Hogan, The Rock, Steve Austin, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Eric Bischoff, Jesse Ventura, Lou Thesz, Jerry Lawler, Mick Foley, Jim Ross, Paul Heyman, Bruno Sammartino, Goldberg, more.

He has interviewed big-name players in person incluiding Vince McMahon (at WWE Headquarters), Dana White (in Las Vegas), Eric Bischoff (at the first Nitro at Mall of America), Brock Lesnar (after his first UFC win).

He hosted the weekly Pro Wrestling Focus radio show on KFAN in the early 1990s and hosted the Ultimate Insiders DVD series distributed in retail stories internationally in the mid-2000s including interviews filmed in Los Angeles with Vince Russo & Ed Ferrara and Matt & Jeff Hardy. He currently hosts the most listened to pro wrestling audio show in the world, (the PWTorch Livecast, top ranked in iTunes)


Wade Keller, editor

James Caldwell, assistant editor

Bruce Mitchell (since 1990)
Pat McNeill (since 2001)
Greg Parks (since 2007)
Sean Radican (since 2003)

We also have a great team of
TV Reporters
and Specialists and Artists.


PWTorch offers a VIP membership for $10 a month (or less with an annual sub). It includes nearly 25 years worth of archives from our coverage of pro wrestling dating back to PWTorch Newsletters from the late-'80s filled with insider secrets from every era that are available to VIPers in digital PDF format and Keller's radio show from the early 1990s.

Also, new exclusive top-shelf content every day including a new VIP-exclusive weekly 16 page digital magazine-style (PC and iPad compatible) PDF newsletter packed with exclusive articles and news.

The following features come with a VIP membership which tens of thousands of fans worldwide have enjoyed for many years...

-New Digital PWTorch Newsletter every week
-3 New Digital PDF Back Issues from 5, 10, 20 years ago
-Over 60 new VIP Audio Shows each week
-Ad-free access to all free articles
-VIP Forum access with daily interaction with PWTorch staff and well-informed fellow wrestling fans
-Tons of archived audio and text articles
-Decades of Torch Talk insider interviews in transcript and audio formats with big name stars.


THE TORCH: #1 IN COMBAT ENTERTAINMENT COVERAGE | © 1999-2013 TDH Communications Inc. • All rights reserved -- PRIVACY POLICY