Select Next Article by Category

WE ARE A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999
|
Torch Feedback
TORCH QUESTION OF THE WEEK Reax #1: First batch of reaction to Bret Hart book (w/JC analysis)
Jan 25, 2008 - 10:20:48 AM |
|
By James Caldwell, Torch columnist
For this week's Question of the Week, we asked Torch readers about their thoughts on Bret Hart after reading his book. How much was their opinion changed - positively or negatively - after reading Bret's detailed account of his life and wrestling career? Let's go to the feedback...
Bill Taylor, Torch reader: Honestly, I thought the book was quite honest and to the point, covering a great portion of the Hitman's career from prior to entering Stampede wrestling, to behind-the-scenes arguments with family and dealings with the WWE. His points going through life are well documented in this book and how he met his first wife and how much he loves his kids. Bret Hart's book could have added a lot more, but I think there was a lot taken out when editing the book for publication. This man's career in pro wrestling has spanned decades and he could easily write another book (becoming something like what Mick Foley is doing). There are guaranteed more stories that he could have told about his life in wrestling outside of his time in Stampede and the WWE. Really, he did not cover the WCW aspect very much, and maybe he could later on in another book. But, overall this was by far the best wrestling book I have ever read!
***
Mark of Toronto, Torch reader: A few thoughts regarding Bret Hart's "Hitman": His work reads very well and very fluidly. He is a natural writer; this shows his passion and how he has said most of the material in the book comes from his notes and voice recordings/journals. Maybe not as eye-opening as Mick Foley's books, but just as great if not better a read. ... He really believes in the honour of the business - from the very first chapters all the way through his WWE career, it all came back to what it meant for the guys in the locker room before what it meant for the bottom dollar. ... I can see why others (like HBK) see him as living in a bubble: there are numerous mention in the book about his creative juices flowing, but him shot down. For instance, the WrestleMania X ladder match - that it was all his idea, even the finish, and how HBK stole it like it was his. Bret drives home over and over again how much this was really his own idea. Bret seems quite insecure about leaving well enough alone. ... I never knew how much he really respected HBK up until about the time of the Clique; that he knew Shawn was a great showman and they each had high respect for one-another's work until business became too personal. ... His candid words about his family are pretty tough sometimes. Jim Neidhart, Dynamite Kid, and Davey Boy are mentioned often and repeatedly as guys who didn't quite understand the business and/or respect it enough. (It's as if Bret was a deity in his own eyes; playing with "kittens" on the road and not understanding why Julie kept breaking things off with him.) ... The best aspect of the book - it's mentioned from very early on - is Bret's perspective on Owen and Owen's life. He is like the "chosen one" in Bret's eyes and it's touching all the way through the read.
***
Jeff Patrus of Roscommon, Mich.: I found Bret Hart's book to be well-written, honest and detailed, and he's an excellent storyteller. However, I must admit I have a lesser opinion of him that I did before I read the book. It seems like he uses "the ends justify the means" theory to justify his marital infidelities. While it's admirable that he at least acknowledges his indiscretions (along with those of others in the wrestling business), he sends a bad message by implying that his indiscretions aren't as bad as those of others in the business. Also, he seems to be very judgmental regarding Shawn Michaels, instead of acknowledging that HBK might be a changed man. I don't doubt that HBK was a primadonna during his first WWE run (before his back surgery), but how would he know about what HBK has gone through, when, as far as I know, the two haven't interacted with each other since the Montreal Screwjob? One particular line, about Shawn being convinced it was Bret that screwed him during the Montreal incident (rather than the other way around) really bothered me. I haven't heard HBK even imply that Bret screwed him, much less outright say that. I think Ted DiBiase made a very wise point in the recently released HBK DVD set, when he talks about Shawn reportedly wanting to bury the hatchet with Bret, but Bret not being interested in returning the favor -- if you're angry and holding a grudge against someone, you're not harming the person to whom you're directing your anger, you're only harming yourself. I just think it's a shame Bret would continue to be that angry. He had a wonderful career, and no question, he had a lot of hardships to deal with since the Montreal incident. I just hope he finds happiness and moves on with his life.
JC: After reading the book and then almost re-reading the final two parts for review purposes, the most difficult evaluation of the book concerns his marriage infidelities and his relationship with Shawn Michaels. As a reviewer, I don't feel it's my place to judge Bret for his obvious indiscretions on the road. I can only evaluate the message he's sending through his accounts. I agree with Jeff that Bret tries to excuse his behavior throughout the book with reasons that he was lonely, he needed a companion, he was stressed out, and his main vice is women. It's an instance when personal choice vs. overwhelming influence of the environment comes into play. Instead of on the prowl, Bret could have been in his hotel room reading a book. Or, were the circumstances too overwhelming to where he needed that companionship to keep his sanity on the road? It's a slippery slope to excuse all unacceptable behavior due to overwhelming and extenuating circumstances.
Regarding Shawn Michaels, I have a little more sympathy for Bret than Shawn because of what Shawn wrote throughout his book about Bret. I've read Shawn's book twice, then I re-read key parts related to Bret last week when doing the Part 4 review of Bret's book. Shawn takes a number of personal and professional shots at Bret throughout the book. And this was coming from the new Shawn. In Bret's book, there are several stories about Shawn and Bret's verbal interaction with each other during their WWF days, and I'm convinced there has always been (and may always be) one massive disconnect in the communication category. It's as if Bret is one side of a bridge, Shawn is on the other side, and in the middle is what's left of a 10-year-old creaky old wood bridge that neither man wants to take the first step to repair. It's amazing how they're still trading blows in their respective autobiographies 10 years later.
You can still contribute! If you've read Bret Hart's book, send in your feedback and thoughts on how your opinion of Bret has changed or been reinforced. Click the "Contact Us" button above and send your feedback to James Caldwell.
For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA, ROH
visit our affiliate: JASON POWELL'S PROWRESTLING.NET
For UFC AND MMA NEWS & BLOGS
visit our affiliate: MMATORCH.COM - now featuring Jamie Penick's MMATorch Daily Audio Updates!
REACT TO THIS STORY IN OUR FREE PWTORCH FORUM
PWTORCH VIP SIGN-UP INFO - NO ADS, EXCLUSIVE CONTENT
|
| MORE "Torch Feedback" ARTICLES
|
(c) 1999-2008 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.
|
|
 |
| PWTorch Free Podcast |
| 12/1 WWE Raw post-game Show: Caldwell and Parks discuss Jericho beat down on John Cena, show filled with missing chapters (7 min. clip) |
| 11/29 Real Deal with Pat McNeill Audio: Torch Awards Preview, Slammys, LAX vs. Briscoes & More (5 min clip) |
| 11/29 Radican Audio Showcase with Burgan: Radican live at Survivor Series, WWE in-depth, TNA Angle DVD (Free 10 min. clip) |
| 11/29 East Coast Audio: Smackdown - Thankful for Edge return, not thankful for Beat the Clock, Show vs. Taker (7 min. clip) |
| 11/28 VIP East Coast Audio: Impact - Young Lions get a name, Too much Triple Threat, Turkeys (7 min. clip) |
| 11/26 East Coast Audio: ECW - Jack Swagger's star-making match, D.J. won't stop dancing, Boogey at the dentist (7 min. clip) |
 |
ARE YOU VIP? SIGN UP NOW FOR $7.50 A MONTH FOR INSTANT ACCESS TO AD-FREE, BENEFIT-PACKED VIP VERSION OF PWTORCH.COM (see screen capture)

INFO ON SUBSCRIPTION TO AD-FREE VIP SITE
INCREDIBLE BENEFITS!
Over 50 full-length audio updates per month (iPod compatible)... New weekly award-winning Pro Wrestling Torch Newsletter (text and printable pdf versions) with latest exclusive insider news, new Torch Talks, great columns, Keller's cover story, much more... Hundreds of full-length back issues of PWTorch Newsletter from late-'80s to today... Ad-free access to PWTorch.com's Main Listing... VIP Forum with interaction with other subscribers and Torch staff... Torch Talk Library with text and audio of hundreds of interview installments from last 20 years... Great layout... Deepest archives on pro wrestling history anywhere... Keller's PWTorch Today PDF Bulletins with email alerts... VIP Email reports on major PPVs and TV shows... Staff Roundtable Reviews (text and audio) followiing major events... The best staff of writers and world class reporting since 1987... We'd love for you to join us and experience the most entertaining, authoritative, experienced staff of professional reporters and commentators in the business... SIGN ME UP NOW!
|
| Articles Grouped by Category |
 |
| Torch Today |
| TORCH STORE: Buy Two, Get One Free November Special on Back Issue Sets, Keller DVD |
| PWTORCH GOES MOBILE: Announcement - Link available now for new Mobile-Customized PWTorch.com site (Blackberry, iPhone, etc.) |
| NOTE ON READER COMMENTS: Some reader comments from yesterday lost due to server upgrade |
 |
| WWE News |
| WWE News: Matt Hardy picks his favorite career wrestling match; discusses high-flying style early in career |
| WWE News: Michael Cole and Joey Styles provide updates from Iraq; new features to Tribute show this year |
| WWE News: Gregory Helms talks about emotional return to the ring after injury rehab and deaths in his family |
 |
| TNA News |
| TNA News: PPV main event signed for this weekend's TNA house shows; house show line-ups prior to Sunday's PPV |
| Ratings News: TNA Impact viewership increases on Thanksgiving, but key demographics take a hit |
| TNA News: Kurt Angle describes mindset coming into WWE; Mick Foley complements himself on evaluating Angle |
 |
| ROH News |
| ROH News: New Video Wire including footage of Samoa Joe's return to ROH (w/VIDEO) |
| RADICAN'S ROH DVD REVIEW: Return Engagement (Ibushi-Generico, Briscoes vs. Shelley & Sabin) |
| ROH News: New Video Wire with Claudio, Nigel, Danielson promos; most random segment ever |
 |
| Other News |
| Other News: Ric Flair on North Carolina's FM Talk 101.1 Wednesday Morning |
| Other News: "The Wrestler" up for several award nominations; famous actor complements Mickey Rourke on lead role |
| Hogan News: Hulk Hogan discusses CCW feud against Vince McMahon, puts over Samoa Joe, discusses WrestleMania 25 opponents |
 |
| PPV Reports |
| KELLER'S WWE PPV REPORT 11/23: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of live event including Jeff Hardy update, Triple H vs. Kozlov, John Cena return |
| CALDWELL'S WWE SURVIVOR SERIES REPORT 11/23: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of John Cena vs. Chris Jericho (w/PICS on-site) |
| RADICAN'S ROH DRIVEN PPV REPORT: Strong-McGuinness, Steen & Generico vs. Black & Jacobs |
 |
| TV Reports |
| CALDWELL'S ECW TV REPORT 12/2: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of WWE's Sci-Fi show featuring Matt Hardy vs. MVP |
| WWE RAW ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS 12/1: Mitchell, Caldwell, Mezzera, Parks rate and review |
| KELLER'S WWE RAW REPORT 12/1: John Cena vs. Kane, Melina vs. Jillian Hall, Stephanie announces huge Raw next week |
 |
| Arena Reports |
| 11/29 WWE in State College, Pa.: Edge changes his look already, Triple H & Jeff Hardy tag team main event |
| 11/12 WWE in Newcastle, U.K.: Batista & Mysterio vs. Jericho & Orton, Shawn Michaels vs. JBL, Haas Hogan in the house |
| WWE News: Complete Smackdown tapings report for next two weeks - Jeff Hardy, Triple H, Koslov set up Survivor Series |
 |
| MMA / UFC Coverage |
| Just Released: MMATorch Middleweight Rankings - Anderson Silva, Lawler, Franklin, Trigg, Cote, Bisping... |
| KELLER: The best movie ever made about MMA that was released 20 years before UFC existed |
| MMATORCH MONDAY RANKINGS: Light-Heavyweight Top Ten Released for 11/24 |
 |
| KELLER'S TAKE |
| KELLER: John Cena is the perfect son Vince McMahon never had |
| KELLER: WWE lacks basic human decency and judgment one again as they tease: Jeff Hardy might be dead! Stay tuned for update! |
| KELLER: ROH's new "subscription" plan falls short in about every regard for its fans |
 |
| MITCHELL'S TAKE |
| MITCHELL SHORT: How WWE's Jim Ross Can Save College Football's Bowl Championship Series |
| MOJO MITCHELL'S RAW 12/1: Stream of Chris Jericho - Responsible Parent; Rey Mysterio - Arm Hurts; DX - Torn and Frayed... |
| MITCHELL SHORT: Dear Stephanie McMahon - It has come to my attention that your... |
 |
| MCNEILL'S TAKE |
| McNEILL: At The Bar For WWE Survivor Series 2008 |
| Spoilin' For A Fight: McNEILL Previews WWE Survivor Series 2008! |
| McNEILL's Mailbag: On The ROH DVD Subscription Service |
 |
| CALDWELL'S TAKE |
| CALDWELL'S MEDIA CLUB: Eddie Guerrero DVD review Day 12 - Eddie vs. Matt Hardy; dealing with a void in life |
| CALDWELL'S MEDIA CLUB: Eddie Guerrero DVD review Day 11 - Eddie moves to WWE; birth of Latino Heat (w/VIDEO) |
| CALDWELL'S MEDIA CLUB: Eddie Guerrero DVD review Day 10 - Vickie Guerrero comments publicly on Eddie's drug use |
 |
| RADICAN'S TAKE |
| TALES FROM THE PULPIT: I was right about John Cena... |
| TALES FROM THE PULPIT 11/18: Too small to be big and too big to be small: ROH's fight to get the buzz back (pt. 1) |
| RADICAN: Last Call with Raven & Sandman dissapoints despite fantastic production and high expectations |
 |
| The Specialists |
| CALDWELL'S MEDIA CLUB: Eddie Guerrero DVD review Day 13 - Eddie vs. Rob Van Dam; Eddie overcomes personal pain |
| THE ABSURDITY REPORT - A COMMON TALE: How Cena Became The Hero Of The Entire WWE Universe |
| 12/1 WWE Raw Hits & Misses: Jericho, Glamarella, JBL's Offer, End of the Show |
 |
| Guest Editorials |
| GUEST MOVIE REVIEW: "The Wrestler" is going to hit close to home for a lot of wrestling fans |
| EDITORIAL: Career vs. Career - The Undertaker vs. John Cena at WrestleMania 25 |
| EDITORIAL: A plan for a dramatic make-over of WWE through massive downscaling of TV, PPVs, roster size, titles |
 |
| Torch Feedback |
| ECW TV Reax #1: "There was a good sign that MVP isn't a totally lost cause..." |
| WWE Smackdown, TNA Impact, and Hulk Hogan CCW Reax #1: "As the weeks have progressed, Hulk has moved more toward the center of attention" |
| WWE Raw Reax #3: "Chris Jericho's opening promo was reliably brilliant." |
 |
| Ask the Editor |
| Ask the Editor: Wouldn't incorporating MMA-style holds into pro wrestling matches just be trying to be something it's not? |
| ASK THE EDITOR: Have the Michaels-Batista promos crossed a line with use of insider terms, references to "jobs"? |
| ASK THE EDITOR: Why do wrestlers in WWE refer to wrestling as "the business" and not "the sport"? |
 |
| DVDs - VGames - Books |
| RADICAN'S ROH DVD REVIEW: Return Engagement (Ibushi-Generico, Briscoes vs. Shelley & Sabin) |
| RADICAN: Last Call with Raven & Sandman dissapoints despite fantastic production and high expectations |
| RADICAN: Hey! The Claudio Castagnoli delivers one of the best independent releases of the year |
 |
| Torch Flashbacks |
| KELLER'S WWE RAW REPORT 5 YRS. AGO (12-01-03): Batista & Randy Orton, Christian and Chris Jericho bet on Trish, Mick Foley as executive share...er...consultant |
| KELLER'S WWE RAW REPORT 5 YRS. AGO (11-24-03): Raw Roulette, Goldberg vs. Triple H, Shawn Michaels & Chris Jericho vs. Ric Flair & Batista |
| WWE News Flashback: Mike Adamle the new G.M. of Raw: Controversial announcer shifted off of ECW announcing duties |
 |
| VIP Exclusive Features |
| 12/2 Daily Keller Hotline: Cena-Jericho hype, TNA PPV hype, Impact quarter hour ratings, SD ratings (16 min.) |
| PWTorch Newsletter #1056 (18 Pages!): Mitchell Feature Column on Mid-Atlantic TV Taping, Radican's Angle DVD Review |
| 12/1 Daily Keller Hotline: Raw gets back to the basics of building feuds - and it works (25 min.) |
 |
| Torch Trivia |
| Torch Trivia: How much do you know about Curt Hennig? - Part Two |
| Torch Trivia: How much do you know about Curt Hennig? - Part One |
| Torch Trivia: How much do you know about Champion vs. Champion matches? |
 |
| Torch Instant Polls |
| Who was the MVP of the Dec. 1 Raw if you saw the show? |
| Rate the 12/1 WWE Raw on a 0-10 scale if you saw the show |
| Who was the MVP of the Nov. 24 Raw is you saw the show? |
 |
| PWTorch Free Podcast |
| 12/1 WWE Raw post-game Show: Caldwell and Parks discuss Jericho beat down on John Cena, show filled with missing chapters (7 min. clip) |
| 11/29 Real Deal with Pat McNeill Audio: Torch Awards Preview, Slammys, LAX vs. Briscoes & More (5 min clip) |
| 11/29 Radican Audio Showcase with Burgan: Radican live at Survivor Series, WWE in-depth, TNA Angle DVD (Free 10 min. clip) |
 |
| Annual Obituaries |
| SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 1999 - Muchnick, Rick Rude, Owen Hart, Renegade... |
| SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2000 - Solie, Albright, Duncum, Tsuruta, Blue Demon, Al Costello |
| SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2001: Johnny Valentine, Terry Gordy, Chris Adams, Bertha Faye, Helen Hart |
 |
|
|