SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...
HITS
KC Navarro getting a win over Bear Bronson and continuing his “momentum”
I’m glad that TNA finally seems to be fully getting behind KC Navarro with a big win at Destination X and now a win tonight against Bear Bronson despite the System’s greatest efforts. The System “miscommunication” and backstage bickering felt a little cartoony to me. This long-lasting breakup angle lacks creativity and has a trope-like feel. Overall the good outweighed the bad here since Navarro should be the highest priority coming out of this match and post-match angle.
Heather by Elegance cleverly hinting at her turn on M by Elegance
I actually liked this backstage angle between the final remaining Elegance Brand members. M has consistently been a jerk to Heather and it’s clear that Heather is over it. Heather subtly hinted at her turning face on M when she promised that M’s poster reveal will go “just the way that it should”. This signals to me that Heather is going to sabotage it because she believes that M deserves it. It might not be Paul Heyman booking but it’s pretty good relative to the Elegance Brand. She later hinted at it again in her backstage segment with Elayna Black.
Mustafa Ali calling out Leon Slater
I am glad that Ali is finally in Slater’s sightline. I do think Ali has to work on yelling his way through many of his promos (something that Nic Nemeth has never learned his entire career). That being said, more wrestlers are being thrown into the World Title mix which is generally a good thing.
Fabian Aichner getting a shot against Jason Hotch for his International Title in two weeks
As Zac Clarke and I have stated countless times on our “Destination Impact” podcast, we love the potential of Fabian Aichner but TNA hasn’t given him much to work with since his debut with the company. Hotch lost much of his momentum with the bungling of the Order 4 breakup and I would be in favor of Aichner taking the title off of Hotch in their match. The one issue I have is that neither Aichner nor AJ Francis, who was also in the backstage segment, have any real justification for a title shot. They always lose. The other wrestler in the segment was Ricky Sosa who just won the TNA X Cup. I would love it if Aichner takes the title off of Hotch in two weeks and this leads to a future Aichner-Sosa match for the International Title.
ARTICLE CONTINUED BELOW…
Check out the latest episode of “Destination Impact” with Zac Clarke and Jerud Buhagiar, part of the PWTorch Dailycast line-up: CLICK HERE to stream (or search “pwtorch” on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or any other iOS or Android app to subscribe free)
MISSES
Tom Hannifin calling Nic Nemeth’s “contractually obligated” rematch clause “long awaited”
Was Nic Nemeth’s contractually obligated rematch clause really “long awaited” when we hadn’t heard about it in months until it was convenient for last week’s main event where Santino inexplicably added the unfair stipulation that Nemeth would lose the rematch if he lost to Elijah (that isn’t the definition of contractually obligated by the way). Wade Keller recently said it best on this week’s AEW post show when he said that “pro wrestling is best when it feels like we aren’t scrambling and rather story beats are being revealed”. This is paraphrased, of course. I’m also tired of Nic Nemeth being so goofy when he’s in the main event title match. He called Gia Miller “Mean Gene” just to be “funny”. He also did his traditional screaming his way through his backstage promo. It just makes everything else feel so non-serious. I can’t wait for the likely Slater-Elijah Vs. the Nemeth Brothers in two weeks after the backstage attack tonight (heavy sarcasm). This isn’t the best way to increase the momentum behind your youngest World Champion and it’s showing in crowd reactions.
Trey Miguel being a bit too much in his “agony of defeat” promo
TNA laid it on a little too thickly tonight with the “grit” and “determination” it took to get through Destination X because of FAA groundings last weekend. I was okay that Hannifin mentioned it to begin the show but I wasn’t a fan of making it such a big part of Miguel’s “agony of defeat” promo. Also, Miguel calling his match with Leon Slater one of the best in TNA history hurt his credibility with me. Nic Nemeth even called out Miguel for whining and complaining in his promo and the crowd cheered it. It felt as though the cheers were almost 50/50 between Miguel and Nemeth. I’d even argue that they pointed in favor of Nemeth. Leon Slater saying that Nic Nemeth had “6,000 ways to die” felt so corny and beneath Slater. Slater got a decent reaction but it wasn’t as strong as it should’ve been coming out of his first title defense.
Is Brian Johnson Daria’s boss or is he her babysitter – the ambiguity is brutal?
I’m still not sure what Brian Johnson’s role is and it seems to change week-to-week without any context as to why it is changing. Does he have legitimate power instilled in him by the board or is he simply there to watch over Daria? If it’s the latter, why is Daria working so hard to convince him to be on her side? Ostensibly, “the board” can see all her weekly interactions with Johnson, and others, because it’s being recorded by an invisible camera on their weekly shows (which I also hate)? Why wouldn’t they intervene? The logic holes here are like Swiss cheese.
Why are people continually awarded for pre-match attacks or beatdowns backstage?
So Allie gets beaten down backstage before what was supposed to be an eight-Knockouts tag match and neither the ref nor the thirty “authority figures” question this or intervene? The babyfaces are just put at a four-on-three disadvantage with no real explanation? I suppose it was to give Shotzi, Forza and Hartwell an excuse for losing to Fire N’ Flava and Apex, but I still don’t think that it justifies the break in immersion due to the lack of structure. Also, Shotzi really needs to cool it with the screaming after every offensive move. The Nemeths are similarly rewarded for attacking Leon Slater backstage, earlier in the show, and injuring his neck before their main event World Title rematch.
The Dollhouse is bad
I have to be completely honest when I say I can’t think of one good thing about the rollout of the new Dollhouse stable since last week’s Impact episode ended with the Dollhouse vignette. Taryn Terrell is an awful promo. Her cadence is beyond irritating and the content was all over the place from her TNA history to why she selected Harley Hudson and Mila Moore (which wasn’t clear to me). Also, the beginning of her promo felt like they were trying to lean babyface while the latter portion of the promo felt more heel-like. By nature of the stable, I imagine they are going to be heels but it hasn’t been made clear to me after Terrell’s mission statement tonight. I also would’ve liked to hear from Hudson and Moore whom this stable should be focused on getting over. I do think that there were several talents more worthy of this spot than Moore but perhaps it was a blessing in disguise for them.
John Skyler is now apparently an oblivious, pathetic loser
Skyler, walking backstage, followed by another invisible camera, hears a female voice say “I know that you’re going through a lot but everything is going to work out”. He looks to his side and says “thanks”. We are then shown a full screen-shot of Elayna Black and M by Elegance clearly standing next to each other and Black says “sorry, but I was talking to M”. The scene was filmed with Skyler walking towards us so how was he unable to see that Black was clearly talking to M? It’s clear TNA sees Skyler as a jobber, which is fine, but my gripe is why do we have to see him on TV every week if his role is so insignificant and we already clearly know that he is a loser.
Xia Brookside wrestles a jobber to complete audience silence in her debut as a Righteous member
I like Xia Brookside but you could hear a pin drop during her first match, against a jobber, as a member of the Righteous. That isn’t a good sign. People aren’t invested in her or the Righteous because we have no idea why they have joined forces or what their motivations are. They just became a stable because it was shocking that Brookside turned on Harley Hudson, I guess. I get that the idea is to give her an edge as an unforgiving force but that cannot be the only note that you hit if you want the fans to care.
Does TNA have any way to decide number one contenders other than multi-men gimmick matches or contractual rematch clauses?
I’m not sure what a Triple Threat Revolver match is but it would’ve been nice if Santino explained it tonight. I’m sure it exists somewhere in TNA lore but I’m not privy to it. Since TNA doesn’t have a new episode next week because of Thanksgiving we have no way of learning the rules until, potentially, the night of the match two Thursdays from now. Does TNA have any other way to decide a number one contender for their World Title other than multi-men gimmick matches or contractual rematch clauses? Why should I be invested in a World Title story if there is no real journey I can be part of which should include racking up wins and earning it? Santino was making Thanksgiving jokes in what should’ve been a serious backstage segment with Matt Hardy and Moose about Hardy’s hatred for SYX. Matt Hardy mentioning how SYX tried to “kill his brother” also took me out of the moment because he’s right and it made me realize how ridiculous it was that it was hardly mentioned and certainly not punished by countless authority figures.
The crowd chanting “We want tables!” during your World Title match and Elijah making an impromptu appearance
You know that your crowd is interested in an outcome when they get to chanting “We want tables!” and you know that they’ll continue to take things seriously when Elijah comes in to save the day from Nic Nemeth using a steel chair. Matt Rehwoldt wasn’t wrong when he said, “Payback can wait. This is your World Title match”. He is right. If the finish to the match for your World Title ends in double chicanery, why should the crowd invest in future World Title matches. The actual in-ring match was okay but it didn’t really live up to what a TNA fan would expect from Nemeth and Slater.