SHOW SUMMARY: In this edition of the Wade Keller Hotline, PWTorch editor Wade Keller presents the Ask the Editor format covering a single topic, and here’s the VIP member question:
I’m listening to your mid-week Livecast (8/31 episode) right now and really enjoying your conversation about cheering Kevin Owens.
I’m having problems relating to your, and your callers’, objections to cheering for Kevin Owens as a heel after he has won a championship. Is your objection that it ruins the narrative structure or that it exposes the fact that fans know better than to buy into the narrative structure? Is it due to a failed bad guy or fans loving the real guy who plays the bad guy?
I love Jim Valley’s concept a “weird work/shoot amalgamation.” That’s what it is; people are cheering for Kevin Steen, not Kevin Owens, and saying that he deserves that championship, which he does, even though his character on TV may not.
I feel like these types of criticisms are clinging onto times in wrestling where kayfabe was all we knew. WWE flat out tells us it’s all a work by exposing themselves behind the scenes on a daily basis. The only time they refuse to do so is through the mics of the announcers, which is interesting.
I do like your point about “creating a monster” with their lack of consistency in their narrative structure. I’m hoping you can elaborate on this dilemma with more nuance. I keep wanting to tell you “you’re too romantic about the past” and I eagerly await your response.
Thanks Wade, I’m really enjoying your coverage these days.
APP USERS: If you are a VIP member accessing this on our app, scroll to the VIP AUDIO LINK below or we also recommend you access audio via a third-party podcast app for iPhone or Android (here’s our list of recommended apps) or via our ad-free VIP Mobile Site’s VIP Audio Show Listing from which you can directly stream or download the shows.
DIRECT LINK: VIP AUDIO LINK